In his 1970 DownBeat interview, Cannonball Adderley reflected on his struggles with the soprano saxophone:
“It’s a total new experience for me because it is not like the alto sax or the tenor sax; it takes another kind of technique to play it well.”
This realization hits home for anyone who has spent serious time with the soprano. I still cringe thinking of my first notes. I actually made the fatal mistake of accepting a recording session after having only own it a few a weeks. Big mistake. I’d just finished, and needed the money. However, the guilt of having sabatoged that poor guys session was not what I needed.
Like me, many saxophonists assume that because it shares fingerings with the alto and tenor, transitioning to it should be straightforward. But Adderley was right—it demands an entirely different approach. The embouchure is less forgiving, air support must be more focused, and the instrument’s inherent instability means that control is everything.
For a musician as masterful as Adderley to acknowledge this speaks volumes. It suggests that even the most accomplished saxophonists cannot simply “pick up” the soprano and expect to sound great. The instrument demands commitment. And people aware of my journey, know that commitment is my middle name.
Adderley was an alto master—his tone, articulation, and phrasing were second to none. But even he quickly recognized that the soprano is its own beast. His words challenge a common assumption among saxophonists: that the soprano is just a smaller saxophone, a quick doubling instrument. In reality, it requires a complete recalibration of approach.
This is something I’ve seen over and over. Many players pick up the soprano for its range and expressiveness, only to struggle with pitch control and sound production. They can play fast, but the notes often end up as some sonic mush. Adderley’s comment reminds us that the soprano doesn’t reward casual engagement. You either put in the work, or the instrument exposes you.
One of Adderley’s keenist observations was about the soprano’s notorious tuning difficulties:
“The technical aspects of being a good soprano saxophone player are frightening. You have to use what we call a tempered intonation concept because you can’t find an instrument that is really built in tune.”
Frightening is the right word. Even today, despite decades of instrument design improvements, a perfectly in-tune soprano saxophone does not exist. The player is responsible for making real-time pitch corrections, often on a subconscious level. It’s not just about knowing which notes are sharp or flat—it’s about developing the ability to bend pitch instinctively while maintaining a consistent sound. Oral cavity awareness is everything.
This is one of the main reasons so few saxophonists truly master the soprano. It requires a heightened sense of intonation compared to other saxophones. On an alto or tenor, you can get away with minor pitch inconsistencies—on a soprano, they stick out like a sore thumb. Adderley clearly grasped this reality early on, and it may explain why he never made the instrument a major part of his voice.
Adderley also touched on the soprano saxophone’s lineage, acknowledging two dominant figures:
“Of course, John Coltrane was the outstanding modern soprano sax player, so it is difficult to find some way to play an instrument which only has the major Sidney Bechet and John Coltrane influences ongoing.”
This is a fascinating statement. In 1970, it was largely true—the soprano saxophone, at least in the jazz world, was still defined by these two giants. Bechet’s explosive, vibrato-heavy New Orleans style represented one lineage, while Coltrane’s modal explorations created a new modern framework. Lacy was around, but he was documenting a lot of his important work in Europe.
But what about today? Have we moved beyond this binary? Absolutely! Steve Lacy pioneered a stark, angular approach, treating the soprano as a vehicle for avant-garde improvisation. Wayne Shorter developed a more fluid, compositional a voice. Jane Ira Bloom, Evan Parker, and Dave Liebman have each pushed the instrument into new sonic territories. And as quiet as it’s kept, Branford Marsalis created a new post-bop/Ornette Coleman sensibility that brought a new generation of saxophonists to the straight horn table.
Adderley's words still resonate today because they capture something every serious soprano player understands: this instrument doesn’t come easy. It requires precision, patience, and a willingness to engage with its challenges. Adderley’s brief encounter with the soprano may not have led to a lasting relationship, but his reflections on it remain as relevant as ever.
For those of us who have put in the time, there’s no greater reward than finding a true voice on the soprano sax. It may not be built in tune, but when played with mastery, there’s nothing else like it.
Here's an example of Cannonball doing his rare soprano thing on his 1968 release, Accent on Africa.
Click here to view full article.
Shout out to all of my straight horn brothers and sisters, spreading the tonal message. These are in no particular order of importance:
Jane Bunnett
Harri Sjöström
Jan Gabarek
Kayla Milmine
Jonathan Kay
Gianni Mimmo
Michael Veal
Michel Doneda
Michael Foster
Rodney Chapman
John Butcher
Vinny Golia
Catherine Sikora
And many others....
No comments:
Post a Comment